Kia Carnival Forum banner
1 - 10 of 10 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
31 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
A few Carnival reviews have started to show up on YouTube over the past couple of days.

 

·
Registered
2021 Odyssey EXL, 2022 Carnival SX
Joined
·
78 Posts
Third video at 8:05 when he passed that Odyssey blind spot monitor DID NOT work , did not detect the van or even at this SX level this safety feature is optional and KIA charges for it ???
Your answer is below
I drove 200 miles across Sierra Nevada to get mine today because the local dealer won't get their SX for another week. Most dealers are willing to sell at MSRP.


Bad Surprise
Blind spot alert is broken - only working intermittently. Already talked to dealer and will have it fixed. Anyone else have this problem?
Seats were the wrong color, they were black not two-tone grey as shown on window sticker. Not that I mind but wow.
I've initially noticed the blind spot detection was working "intermittently" but later realized it may be designed to work differently as part of Hyundai/Kia's "award winning blind spot safety system". This is what I noticed: if my relative speed to vehicles in a adjacent lane is more than 10mph (i.e. overtaking speed), the blind spot system will not go off even if you pass another car all the way through blind spot. In all other scenarios - cruising, getting passed by another car, or driving slightly faster than the other car, the system gives you warning 100% if there is any moving object in the blind spots.

I think there is a design rationale to this - if you are aggressively overtaking a car, you are presumably aware the car you are passing in this case there is no "blind spot" and the lane change assist active safety mechanism (actively steering for collision avoidance) would not engage. Kia simply applied the the active system logic to the detection algorithm, but many new owners such as myself did not know this system works very differently from all other "dumb" blind spot detectors.

Initially Kia was going to send a field service tech to check on my car but now I told them if they can confirm that this is a design feature, we can save the trip and I'll get used to it. Yes my personal preference would be turn off the active safety and have my "dumb detection" just like every other car, but I could get used to the new design as long as it works highly consistently and predictably. Could the other new owners confirm your experience here?
Update: received answer from Kia the overtaking speed differential to disable blind spot warning is indeed 10mph or 15kmph.
 

·
Registered
2021 Odyssey EXL, 2022 Carnival SX
Joined
·
78 Posts
So it means if there is smack dab in the middle of my blind spot an 18 wheeler the "Award Winning" "smart" system considers circumstances and decides if I should be notified about it.
Yep
 
1 - 10 of 10 Posts
Top